Overall verdict: 4/10
The Good: Decent art and animation from the Megazone 23 footage, catchy songs, good background music
The Bad: Mediocre voice acting, slip shod editing, clashing art styles, misuse of good music, plot lacks coherence, dull dialogue
***********Review***********
In the mid 80s, Successful animated series like G I Joe and Transformers were getting theatrical movie releases. Naturally a budding franchise like Robotech would want to jump on the band wagon.
The tumultuous production of this Robotech movie, otherwise known as "Robotech: The Untold Story", resulted in a complete mess.
What was to be a straight up dub of the "Megazone 23 part 1" OVA modified to fit into the Robotech Macross Saga time-frame became a horribly edited mish mash of Megazone and Superdimensional Southern Cross because Japanese anime studio Tatsunoko prevented Carl Macek from using elements from Macross and the distributor, Cannon Films, demanded more action footage.
"The Untold story" (now relegated to secondary canon, thankfully) tells the tale of the Robotech Masters' first attack against earth and its subsequent cover up (hence why the characters featured in season 2 of Robotech were not aware of this first invasion attempt).
During a skirmish, they capture a high ranking military officer Col B.D Andrews and create a clone of him to cover up the actions of the Robotech Masters.
During a skirmish, they capture a high ranking military officer Col B.D Andrews and create a clone of him to cover up the actions of the Robotech Masters.
While The clone keeps the public unaware, the Masters seek to hack into the earth forces' computers and recover the information stored within the "Memory matrix" that was on board the SDF-1 when it first crashed to earth decades ago.
On the ground, a young biker named Mark Landry discovers a transformable Robot vehicle with information about the cover up conspiracy.
Now hunted by the clone Andrews, Mark must make contact with E.V.E, the artificial intelligence inside the Memory Matrix, and uncover the conspiracy before the Robotech Masters succeed in their plans.
On the ground, a young biker named Mark Landry discovers a transformable Robot vehicle with information about the cover up conspiracy.
Now hunted by the clone Andrews, Mark must make contact with E.V.E, the artificial intelligence inside the Memory Matrix, and uncover the conspiracy before the Robotech Masters succeed in their plans.
If the synopsis did not sound coherent here, it is 10 times less so in the actual movie and the clashing animation styles only serve to enhance that fact.
The quality of the artwork, from a high quality OVA and a mediocre TV series respectively, do not blend at all and is highly inconsistent.
Slip shod editing rendered the narrative very difficult to follow. You even have scenes with characters talking to each other and the background changes during the same dialogue when it cuts to another angle of the scene. It makes the entire movie feel like exactly what it was: two separate shows edited together with little effort to make them match.
The quality of the artwork, from a high quality OVA and a mediocre TV series respectively, do not blend at all and is highly inconsistent.
Slip shod editing rendered the narrative very difficult to follow. You even have scenes with characters talking to each other and the background changes during the same dialogue when it cuts to another angle of the scene. It makes the entire movie feel like exactly what it was: two separate shows edited together with little effort to make them match.
For fans who have watched the original Robotech series, the Southern Cross stock footage is so out of context that it is funny. You hear a deep male voice coming from Dana Sterling's Veritech (there is even a brief shot of Dana yelling in a man's voice ordering a retreat) or when a characters who are obviously Louie Nicols and Angelo Dante refer to each other as Todd and Nick respectively.
Barring the drastic changes from its source material, Megazone 23, the film would fare no better even if one does not compare it to Megazone.
The characters in the Robotech movie are two dimensional good guys or bad guys but thankfully Mark Landry does get a decent character development arc going from hot headed irresponsible punk to a genuine hero.
The characters in the Robotech movie are two dimensional good guys or bad guys but thankfully Mark Landry does get a decent character development arc going from hot headed irresponsible punk to a genuine hero.
One positive point could have been the number of catchy songs that were written specifically for this movie. They remain among the best songs ever in the Robotech soundtrack; even famous Rock band "Three Dog Night" contributed a piece.
The conspiracy storyline was well plotted and effective at keeping you guessing but, as mentioned earlier, both positive points were also marred by horrible execution. The songs were used in with the most inappropriate scenes as if the creative team just inserted the songs to fill in long gaps of silence.
The conspiracy storyline was well plotted and effective at keeping you guessing but, as mentioned earlier, both positive points were also marred by horrible execution. The songs were used in with the most inappropriate scenes as if the creative team just inserted the songs to fill in long gaps of silence.
Movies that were hastily re-edited at the last minute would forever remain exactly that. Robotech: The Untold Story suffered that fate and the disappointing result clearly shows.
Would harmony gold have produced a better movie if Tatsunoko and cannon films had not imposed their restrictions? That is hard to say as the original concept never went beyond a film pitch. But lamenting a movie that could have been does not change what something is.
And Robotech: The Untold Story is a story that should be left untold. A disappointment so bad that even the original creator denounced it.
Would harmony gold have produced a better movie if Tatsunoko and cannon films had not imposed their restrictions? That is hard to say as the original concept never went beyond a film pitch. But lamenting a movie that could have been does not change what something is.
And Robotech: The Untold Story is a story that should be left untold. A disappointment so bad that even the original creator denounced it.
***********Review***********
Entertainment: C+
Art: B-
Animation: C
Story: D+
Voice Acting (English): B+
Characters: C
Music: B
Replay value: C-
"Brains": D
No comments:
Post a Comment