The Good: Decent character design, good voice acting, more natural character interactions, serves as an intriguing pilot movie, nostalgic revisiting of classic characters.
The Bad: inconsistent artwork, horrible pacing, over use of repeated animation, some questionable new designs.
***********Review***********
ROBOTECH II: THE SENTINELS was meant to be the start of a new series following the adventures off the ROBOTECH: THE MACROSS SAGA characters on an expedition mission the the far reaches of space.
A myriad of reasons caused production to be halted and only less than 3 episodes worth of material was ever completed. Despite the various setbacks, Harmony gold edited the remaining completed material into a 75 minute feature meant to bridge the gap between the first and second Robotech sagas.
Following the defeat of the giant Zentradi armada, the remaining Zentradi have joined forces with the humans to build a massive vessel, the SDF-3. They intend to reach the home-world of the Robotech Masters, the masterminds behind the Zentradi invasion, and establish peaceful relations with them.
Thanks to the truncated nature of the completed animation, the movie is split into two story arcs. The first takes place around earth. As the heroes of the first Robotech war prepare for their interstellar voyage, new heroes try to earn their place among those chosen for the expedition.
Here we are introduced to the hot headed Jack Baker and the intelligent and spirited Karen Penn. Re-introduced are the characters from the Macross saga like Rick Hunter and Lisa Hayes, who are in the midst of planning their wedding. Fans would no doubt get a kick out of seeing their favorite characters, older but instantly recognisable as the same people they knew and loved.
The second story arc takes place around Tirol, the home-world which the Robotech Masters abandoned to search for the lost protoculture matrix, leaving their old, sick and young behind.
The invid led by the dreaded Regent (husband of the Regiss) takes this opportunity to launch an all out invasion of Tirol. Amidst the decimation, an aging scientist called Cabell and a familiar looking man named Rem try to survive and carry on their research.
As expected, the earth scenes featuring the recurring macross saga characters are pretty much all talk and no action other than a combat simulation at the beginning.
Most of the action takes place during the Tirol invasion scenes. Thankfully the voice actors put up an excellent performance and the script keeps the dialog very natural preventing the slower scenes from feeling dull.
Many fans have lamented the lower quality animation but really, the artwork is no less inconsistent than what was in the original series and the animation is actually on par with the The Masters season. It is sub par for a movie but one must remember that Robotech II The Sentinels was produced as a TV series.
While there are scenes with better than usual animation, such as the opening sequence with Jack Baker and Rick Hunter flying their Alphas, there are also a lot of animation short cuts, repeated animation to pad out the run time, and even unfinished animation.
Another common complaint is the altered character designs for the returning Macross saga characters. Keep in mind that this show takes place 8 years after Macross saga. Eight years can do a lot to someone's appearance especially characters like Rick Hunter and Lynn Minmei who went from teenagers to full adults.
If anything, the changes in appearances of said characters gives a sense of realism of the series, showing that characters do not remain immortally young unlike other TV animated shows.
Visual changes aside, the music was also changed for this movie. There is much more reliance on synthesiser music which can be a mixed bag. This style is great for fast paced scenes, or scenes involving the alien invid. Outside of those, the music sounds like something out of a generic video game.
While this show does provide some answers for fans, no one else but fans who have watched the original series would be able to understand it. Furthermore The Sentinels concludes rather abruptly; actually showing the SDF-3 leaving earth would have been a much more fulfilling conclusion but given the limited resources available, this is also not unexpected.
Despite the valiant effort of the creative team, Robotech II: The Sentinels loses points for its abrupt ending, inconsistent story and mediocre animation for a movie. It serves as a decent enough teaser for any fan looking to follow the rest of the unfinished tale in the Robotech novels or comics.
For fans of Robotech, watching Robotech II The Sentinels would be like returning to visit a family that one has not seen in years. It is a quick simple visit to catch up on old times and marvel at how much they have changed over the years, nothing more nothing less.
***********Review***********
ROBOTECH II: THE SENTINELS was meant to be the start of a new series following the adventures off the ROBOTECH: THE MACROSS SAGA characters on an expedition mission the the far reaches of space.
A myriad of reasons caused production to be halted and only less than 3 episodes worth of material was ever completed. Despite the various setbacks, Harmony gold edited the remaining completed material into a 75 minute feature meant to bridge the gap between the first and second Robotech sagas.
Following the defeat of the giant Zentradi armada, the remaining Zentradi have joined forces with the humans to build a massive vessel, the SDF-3. They intend to reach the home-world of the Robotech Masters, the masterminds behind the Zentradi invasion, and establish peaceful relations with them.
Thanks to the truncated nature of the completed animation, the movie is split into two story arcs. The first takes place around earth. As the heroes of the first Robotech war prepare for their interstellar voyage, new heroes try to earn their place among those chosen for the expedition.
Here we are introduced to the hot headed Jack Baker and the intelligent and spirited Karen Penn. Re-introduced are the characters from the Macross saga like Rick Hunter and Lisa Hayes, who are in the midst of planning their wedding. Fans would no doubt get a kick out of seeing their favorite characters, older but instantly recognisable as the same people they knew and loved.
The second story arc takes place around Tirol, the home-world which the Robotech Masters abandoned to search for the lost protoculture matrix, leaving their old, sick and young behind.
The invid led by the dreaded Regent (husband of the Regiss) takes this opportunity to launch an all out invasion of Tirol. Amidst the decimation, an aging scientist called Cabell and a familiar looking man named Rem try to survive and carry on their research.
As expected, the earth scenes featuring the recurring macross saga characters are pretty much all talk and no action other than a combat simulation at the beginning.
Most of the action takes place during the Tirol invasion scenes. Thankfully the voice actors put up an excellent performance and the script keeps the dialog very natural preventing the slower scenes from feeling dull.
Many fans have lamented the lower quality animation but really, the artwork is no less inconsistent than what was in the original series and the animation is actually on par with the The Masters season. It is sub par for a movie but one must remember that Robotech II The Sentinels was produced as a TV series.
While there are scenes with better than usual animation, such as the opening sequence with Jack Baker and Rick Hunter flying their Alphas, there are also a lot of animation short cuts, repeated animation to pad out the run time, and even unfinished animation.
Another common complaint is the altered character designs for the returning Macross saga characters. Keep in mind that this show takes place 8 years after Macross saga. Eight years can do a lot to someone's appearance especially characters like Rick Hunter and Lynn Minmei who went from teenagers to full adults.
If anything, the changes in appearances of said characters gives a sense of realism of the series, showing that characters do not remain immortally young unlike other TV animated shows.
Visual changes aside, the music was also changed for this movie. There is much more reliance on synthesiser music which can be a mixed bag. This style is great for fast paced scenes, or scenes involving the alien invid. Outside of those, the music sounds like something out of a generic video game.
While this show does provide some answers for fans, no one else but fans who have watched the original series would be able to understand it. Furthermore The Sentinels concludes rather abruptly; actually showing the SDF-3 leaving earth would have been a much more fulfilling conclusion but given the limited resources available, this is also not unexpected.
Despite the valiant effort of the creative team, Robotech II: The Sentinels loses points for its abrupt ending, inconsistent story and mediocre animation for a movie. It serves as a decent enough teaser for any fan looking to follow the rest of the unfinished tale in the Robotech novels or comics.
For fans of Robotech, watching Robotech II The Sentinels would be like returning to visit a family that one has not seen in years. It is a quick simple visit to catch up on old times and marvel at how much they have changed over the years, nothing more nothing less.
***********Review***********
Entertainment: B-
Art: C-
Animation: C
Art: C-
Animation: C
Story: C+
Voice Acting (English): A
Voice Acting (English): A
Characters: B
Music: B-
Replay value: B-
"Brains": D-
"Brains": D-
No comments:
Post a Comment